
| Show Title | Synopsis | Fans |
| Martin Guerre | Taking place in 1560, ‘Martin Guerre’ tells the story of two friends who loves the same woman. ... | 10 |
| Pinocchio (Prince Street Players' Version) | Taking place in Italy, the musical tells the classic tale of a wooden puppet who wants to become a r... | 10 |
| Zanna Don't | Zanna, Don't! is set in a world where homosexuality is the norm, and heterosexuals are considered an... | 10 |
| Caroline, Or Change | The musical is set in 1963 Lake Charles and revolves around the relationship between Caroline, an Af... | 10 |
| Pal Joey | By using his self-confidence and cockiness, Joey Evans manages to get an M.C. gig at Mike’s cl... | 9 |
| Gigi | ‘Gigi’ is the story of a young French girl trained by her Aunt Alicia to be a courtesan.... | 9 |
| Side by Side by Sondheim | ‘Side by Side by Sondheim’ is a musical revue focusing on both famous and obscure songs by Broad... | 9 |
| Treasure Island | ‘Treasure Island’ is the musical version of this favorite childhood adventure story. It is a thr... | 9 |
| Godspell Junior | Based on the Gospel According to St. Matthew and drawing from various theatrical traditions, such as... | 9 |
| No, No Nanette | Even though Jimmy Smith has become a millionaire due to his bible publishing business, his wife Sue ... | 8 |
| Paint Your Wagon | After years of searching for gold out West, Ben Rumson and his young daughter, Jennifer, strike it r... | 8 |
| Falsettos | Falsettos is the story of a confused, bisexual man, Marvin, amidst a Jewish family in New York. Ini... | 8 |
| Carmen Jones | In a Southern town during World War II, parachute maker Carmen Jones successfully seduces a soldier ... | 8 |
| The Woman in White | ‘The Woman in White’ is a story of love, betrayal and greed. The show revolves around two women,... | 8 |
| The Civil War | ‘The Civil War’ uses letters, diaries, historical documents and Walt Whitman's poetry to explore... | 8 |
| Sugar | The plot concerns Joe and Jerry, unemployed musicians in 1929 Chicago, who inadvertently witness a g... | 8 |
| Allegro | The show chronicles nearly four decades in the life of an average American, Joseph Taylor, Jr., from... | 7 |
| Anyone Can Whistle | Anyone Can Whistle is a musical about political corruption and the vague definition of sanity. The ... | 7 |
| High Fidelity | The show follows the adventures of Rob, a record store owner who knows almost everything there is to... | 7 |
| Vanities | Chronicling the comic journey of three bubbly Texas teens from cheerleaders to sorority sisters to h... | 7 |