
| Show Title | Synopsis | Fans |
| Peter Pan (Charlop/Styne) | 'Peter Pan' tells the story of a mischievous little boy who refuses to grow up. Peter Pan spends his... | 119 |
| Carousel | After the mill girl, Julie Jordan, marries that handsome, but uncivilized carousel barker, Billy Big... | 118 |
| Sunday in the Park with George | In nineteenth-century France, Georges struggles with his art and his personal life. As George is co... | 113 |
| Kiss Me Kate | The egotistical performer Fred Graham is reunited with his ex-wife Lilli Vanessi in the leading rol... | 110 |
| Crazy for You | In Crazy For You a stage-struck New York playboy, Bobby Child, is sent to a small, poor town in Neva... | 109 |
| Parade | ‘Parade’ concerns the true story of the 1913 trial of a Brooklyn-born Jewish factory manager Leo... | 107 |
| The Drowsy Chaperone | The show revolves around one musical theatre fan’s obsession with a fictional show from the 1920s ... | 104 |
| The King and I | It's the 1860's and the Western world is closing in on Thailand. Hoping to give his family ... | 102 |
| Alice in Wonderland (Prince Street Players' Version) | This is the musical version of Lewis Carroll’s classic book. Our hero, Alice falls down an enc... | 101 |
| The Wiz | While similar in plot to “The Wizard of Oz”, The Wiz (usually) uses an all-black cast to... | 100 |
| All Shook Up | Built around the songs made famous by Elvis Presley, All Shook Up tells the story of a small town gi... | 97 |
| Man of La Mancha | The story takes place in the late 16th century. Miguel de Cervantes (a tax collector, soldier, and ... | 96 |
| Assassins | 'Assassins' is the odd story about 9 individuals who over time have attempted to assassinate the Pre... | 91 |
| The Wizard of Oz (Prince Street Players' Version) | After a tornado whisks away a young Kansas farm girl, Dorothy, to the magical land of OZ, she starts... | 89 |
| Sweet Charity | Charity Valentine is the eternal optimist. While working at the seedy Fan-Dango ballroom, she is of... | 85 |
| Bare | The musical is about the coming-of-age story of five high school seniors at a Catholic boarding scho... | 84 |
| Fantasticks | Two fathers decide that they want their children to fall in love. The girl, Luisa, is a daydreamer ... | 80 |
| The Light in the Piazza | ‘The Light in the Piazza’ takes place in Italy during the summer of 1953. It is a love story of... | 73 |
| Aladdin Junior (Disney) | Disney’s Aladdin Junior brings the famous movie to life again on stage. In Agrabah, City of Encha... | 73 |
| Damn Yankees | Joe Boyd is a typical middle-aged man who is addicted to baseball. Every baseball season is painful... | 70 |