We just did Anything Goes at our high school this summer. It's an absolutely fantastic show! Now, for the best version of the soundtrack, the one that I've heard most theatre groups use, and the one that I've enjoyed listening to the most, is the 1987 Patti LuPone version. However, our high school used the 1962 Eileen Rodgers version. It all depends on personal preference, I suppose. Now, as for tapdancing, I could not tap dance AT ALL and I played Reno Sweeney. The lead roles don't really need to tapdance, although comfort in movement is vital. However, If you end up getting Reno (great role. amazing role. extremely fun role.) you will have to lead the tap number during the finale of Act I. (Anything Goes) I hope you have a great time with this awesome musical, and break a leg!